Is Selling on Etsy Worth it in 2024? (Reviews & Alternatives)

Selling on Etsy is worth it in 2024 because it’s one of the quickest, cheapest, and easiest ways to get your handmade products online and hooked up with a shopping cart function. It’s also a low-risk option when compared to building a website. You can set up a professional-looking online shop in a matter of hours, list several items for just a few dollars, and not have to deal with domain and hosting fees.

Although you may not immediately reap the benefits of Etsy’s shoppers, your existing customers will immediately have a way to shop and buy from you.

As soon as your Etsy shop is set up and you have a few listings, you can share a link to it on social media or email it to friends and family, asking them to pass your link on to others.

It takes time to learn the ropes on Etsy and a certain amount of skill to get your listings to appear at the top of search results. But it takes much longer to get a new website to appear in the top search results of Google.

For these reasons, I believe Etsy is one of the best ways to sell handmade items, vintage items, or craft supplies online and is worth it for a craft business to start selling on while they work on building a website.

Of course, before you set up an Etsy shop, be sure you’re following the laws around operating a handmade business:

- LAWS FOR SELLING HANDMADE

PROS & CONS OF SELLING ON ETSY

Etsy has made several changes lately, and they’ll continue to do so. Etsy’s top priority is for Etsy to make money, so they’re going to do what’s best for their business, not yours.

The recent changes seem to reflect that as there are many upset Etsy sellers wondering if it’s worth it to continue selling on the platform.

To help you determine if Etsy is worth it for yourhandmade business, here are a few of the most common Etsy pros and cons:

ETSY PROS

1. QUICK, EASY & COST EFFECTIVE

It’s easy to set up an online store and keep costs low. When you build a website, you must either pay someone to design and build it for you or invest hours into building it yourself. You’ll also have domain and hosting fees.

Etsy also makes it easy to add listings, edit listings, and update your shop.

2. ETSY HAS AN ESTABLISHED AUDIENCE

If you were to start a website today, it would take months, maybe even years, for search engines to pick it up and to appear on the first page of Google. And Google is a much more competitive platform than Etsy since it lists every website in the world. Etsy allows you to set up an online store and have the potential for shoppers to see it immediately.

3. GOOD TESTING GROUND

Selling on Etsy is a great way to start your business and test the market before investing more time and money into a website. There’s so much to learn and do when it comes to starting a handmade business. Etsy takes building and maintaining a website off that list.

Start to earn money, build your brand, get to know your customers, etc. first, before you add more to your plate. Everything you learn from selling on Etsy can help ensure you hit the ground running when you launch your website.

ETSY CONS

1. COMPETITION

Although Etsy is well-known and attracts lots of shoppers, it’s also well-known to other handmade business owners. It’s become quite competitive over the years and every category is saturated, so you can no longer rely on Etsy driving shoppers to your shop.

You must work or pay for those shoppers.

That time and money could be put into building your own audience of loyal customers who shop on your website and aren’t distracted by thousands of other sellers or handmade items.

2. COPYCATS

Because so many crafters know about Etsy, it makes it easy for them to find your product and copy it.

I don’t like to provoke fear and I would never encourage you to notput your work out there because of copycats; it’s likely to eventually happen whether you’re on Etsy or not.

But the better jump start you have on establishing your brand and becoming known for offering your unique product, the harder time copycats will have taking customers away from you. On Etsy, those copycat products are sitting right next to yours and are just a click away for shoppers.

3. LACK OF CUSTOMER LOYALTY

When shoppers sign up for your newsletter, follow your social media accounts, and visit your website, it’s because they’re a fan of your brand. When people head to Etsy’s website, it’s because they’re a fan of Etsy and they’re looking for handmade products…not specifically yourhandmade products.

They’re going to come across several sellers offering similar products and may choose based on which shop has the lowest prices, fastest shipping, etc.

It’s like shopping at the grocery store. You likely don’t know the farmers who produced the vegetables and may not even care which farm they come from, as long as there’s a good selection for you to choose from.

But let’s say you’ve gotten to know a local farmer. You’ve seen the land they grow their vegetables on, you’ve met the farm owners, you know their processes, etc. it’s likely you’ll feel more loyalty to that farmer and will make the effort to buy vegetables from them.

On Etsy, it’s hard for you to set your shop apart, which makes it harder for Etsy shoppers to get to know you and your brand to create brand loyalty. This brings me to my next point…

4. LACK OF BRANDING

A business’s brand should come through in many ways, but Etsy only gives you control of a few of those touchpoints.

For example, on your website, you can change the colors, fonts, navigation, layout, shopping experience, etc. but those aren’t things you can adapt on Etsy.

Etsy shoppers can only get to know your brand through your shop’s name, the images you upload, and the text you use.

Let’s say my brand is high-end. I’d have a hard time making my Etsy shop look and feel much higher-end than my Etsy competitors because we have the same font, font colors, layout, etc.

On the other hand, I’m in control of every element on my website and can make every detail that surrounds my products feel “high-end” so my prices seem justified to shoppers.

5. HARDER TO GROW YOUR EMAIL LIST

Email marketing is one of the most effective ways to market, so it’s important for every handmade business to have a newsletter.It’s also a great way to keep in touch with your buyers and provide great customer service after a transaction.

It is possible to market your newsletter on Etsy, but at this time, you’re unable to have a signup form directly in your Etsy shop.

Getting people to sign up for your newsletter when the form is right in front of them is one task. Adding more steps for a person to get to that form makes them less likely to sign up.

You can still collect email addresses, even if you don’t have a website setup. So it’s worth it to start a newsletter and link to a signup form from your Etsy shop.

It takes 10 minutes to set up a landing page form, and it’s free. Here’s how:

SELLING ON ETSY REVIEWS

Etsy reviews can also help you determine if it’s worth it for you to sell on the platform. You can find reviews for Etsy on sites such as:

Sitejabber
Trustpilot
Consumer Affairs

One thing to keep in mind when looking at Etsy’s overall rating on sites like these is that the reviews are from both buyers and sellers.

Buyers are leaving 1-star reviews for Etsy based on one seller they dealt with. That 1-star should go to the seller, not Etsy. These types of reviews can skew the results when you’re wondering if it’s worth it for you to sell on Etsy.

Thereareplenty of reviews from sellers too, most of them aren’t great. But when you look at the number of reviews an Etsy rating is based on, you’ll see it’s a fraction of how many people are actually using Etsy.

If you takejustEtsy sellers, the most recent stat I found was for 2019, which stated there were 2.69 Etsy seller (source).

So let’s take a look at the review sites that have Etsy reviews and count how many of those reviews are 3 stars or less:

Sitejabber: 790 out of 2033 people reviewed Etsy as 3 stars or less

Trustpilot: 2229 out of 3231 people reviewed Etsy as 3 stars or less

Consumer Affairs: they don’t break their numbers down but based on their graph, it looks like maybe 30 – 40% of people reviewed Etsy as 3 stars or less. So if we go down the middle and say 35%, that would be 280 people.

Of those 3 sites that have Etsy reviews, an approximate total of 3299 people gave Etsy 3 stars or less when reviewing the platform.

If we divide those poor Etsy reviews by the estimated number of sellersEtsy had in 2019, that’s not even 1% of people who are unhappy with the platform; it’s 0.12%.

Keep in mind, that number is not based on sorting each Etsy review into who’s reviewing as an Etsy buyer and who’s reviewing as an Etsy seller. It’s taking the total number of bad reviews and dividing it by how many active sellers there were in 2019.

If we take the total number of Etsy users, which I’m guessing is the number of people who have created an account on Etsy and include buyers and sellers, that’s 46.35 million in 2019 (source).

So when you take all of Etsy’s 3-star, or lower, reviews (3299) which includes buyer and sellers, and divide it by totalEtsy users, which includes buyers and sellers, the percentage of Etsy users that aren’t very happy with Etsy is 0.007%.

I know not everyone who has used Etsy has left a review on one of these websites, but those numbers give you an idea of the percent of Etsy users who had a bad enough experience to leave a bad review.

There will always be pros and cons to every business. When you’re as big as Etsy, you can’t please everyone.

To get a better idea of sellers’ experiences on Etsy, take a closer look at some shops that are similar to yours.

>> How long have they been on Etsy? Several years tells you they must be somewhat satisfied with their experience.

>> How many sales do they have? Do remember that how much marketing the seller does will have a direct impact on how many sales they have.

You can also head to the Etsy forums and look up some more specific questions to see how Etsy sellers respond. Are they generally happy or unhappy with Etsy?

What are some Etsy alternatives?

If you want to sell online, but are fed up with Etsy or don’t think it’s worth your time and money, there are many other options for you to choose from.

If you’re going to choose an alternative online marketplace, look for one that targets a different audience than Etsy and is focused on a different category (e.g. a marketplace for selling knitted goods or one for art).

If you’re looking for a general handmade marketplace, Etsy is ranked top in that category by most handmade businesses (Amazon Handmade would be second).

You can check out a full list of those marketplaces here: 30+ ETSY ALTERNATIVES

The list also includes options such as starting your own website, adding a shopping cart function to your Facebook page, and free options for selling handmade online.

Is it profitable to sell on Etsy?

It can be profitable to sell on Etsy if you’re selling a product with high profit margins. There are several overhead costs to consider when selling on Etsy that will reduce your profits, and even have sellers losing money.

You may also want to check out:

The Most Profitable Crafts to Sell
How Much Does Etsy Take Per Sale?
How to Find the Best Things to Sell on Etsy

You also want to consider the type of product you’re planning to sell on Etsy, and if it’s commonly shopped for and purchased online.

There are a few things that must be kept in mind when it comes to handmade items that sell well on Etsy:

1 – Online Shopping Behavior

2 – Handmade trends

3 – Shipping fees

1 – ONLINE SHOPPING BEHAVIOR

People head online to shop for a few main reasons:

Specific items

If you saw your favorite celebrity wearing a yellow sundress with ruffle sleeves and wanted to find one just like it, would you head to the mall and stop in ALL of the stores? Or head online and type “yellow sundress with ruffle sleeves” into Google?

The second option is easier right?

When selling on Etsy, you must think about which details online shoppers might be specifically searching for and what type of wants/needs drive them to shop online. For example, most people aren’t heading online to find a “women’s dress”. Instead, one may be looking for a “yellow sundress with ruffle sleeves”.

When you know the specific product features your target market is searching for, you can be sure to name them in your product title and description, so your listing gets found.

Even if you aren’t sure what your target market is searching for, your listings are more likely to be discovered when your titles are specific.

No one is searching the Internet for “soap”, so online shoppers are unlikely to discover an Etsy listing titled “soap”. Soap can be easily found at the grocery store or drugstore.

If someone is going online to find soap, it’s because they’re looking for a specific type of soap.Maybe it’s unicorn-themed soap for their child, or food-themed soap as a gift for their foodie friend, or turmeric-infused soap because they read about turmeric’s beauty benefits.

Soap listings using the same keywords online shoppers are typing into search bars are more likely to be discovered.

>> Here’s how to determine which keywords your potential customers are using and how to use keywords to bring more traffic to your Etsy shop.

>> You may also be interested in the best and most basic Etsy SEO tips

Do Etsy sellers make a lot?

There are many people who open Etsy shops and don’t make a penny.

This tends to happen when the seller thinks it’s as easy as listing a few items and waiting for Etsy to bring shoppers to them.

Looking at some of the top-selling Etsy shops, they tend to make over six figures a year, some look like they may be earning over a million dollars in revenue per year.

>> Here’s what the worst-selling Etsy shops have in common and how to avoid their mistakes

*Revenue is much different than profit. The more products you create and sell, the higher your expenses are. Check out The Success Plannerfor more clarification on business numbers and how to improve yours.

It’s also important to keep in mind, most of the shops earning over six figures per year are selling products that may not technically be considered handmade (or have as many handmade elements as other products listed on Etsy).

However, anyone can list a lower-priced, mass-produced item on Etsy, but it doesn’t mean they’ll sell thousands of that item and earn over six figures in a year.

There’s a strategy for growing an Etsy shop, no matter how handmade or un-handmade an item is.

I took a closer look at an Etsy shop that sells jewelry and has consistently been a top-selling Etsy shop for years.

Yes, her products may not have as many handmade elements to them as someone who assembles every piece of their jewelry, but they still have amazing business practices in place that any business can implement to improve their sales.

You can take a closer look at a top-selling Etsy shop here.

Earning over six figures on Etsy is NOT typical.

There are many sellers struggling to make one sale each day, so there really isn’t a typical number you can expect to earn. The sky is the limit…if you put the work in.

The key to more sales is to go after a bigger piece of a small pie, rather than a small piece of a big pie.

Most Etsy shops are trying to turn as many customers as possible into customers.

For example, jewelry businesses list products on Etsy to sell to “women”. But targeting women is going after a very big pie. There’s so much competition that it’s hard to capture many customers.

If instead, a jewelry business targets mothers who have daughters and sells matching mother-daughter pieces, they’re now going for a smaller pie but they can get a bigger piece because there aren’t as many jewelry businesses vying for it.

Making a bunch of products and then looking for customers is like making a key and running around looking for a lock for it to open.

Start with the lock you want to open and then create a key to open it.

>> How to Find a Goldmine of Customerswill help you do that and give you a better chance of making more sales on Etsy.

Once you know the niche you want to target on Etsy, take a look at your Etsy competitors.

This approach will give you a more accurate idea of how much money you have the potential to make on Etsy.

HOW TO ESTIMATE HOW MUCH MONEY YOU CAN MAKE ON ETSY:

STEP 1 – Check Product Category

Go to the category your handmade items would fall under on Etsy. For example, if I make candles, I would go to Home & Living -> Candles.

STEP 2 – Find Competing Items

Look for a listing that’s similar to the products you plan to sell on Etsy. For example, if I sell candles in jars with humorous labels, I would look for candles with humorous labels.

Click on those listings and then click on the shop name to visit that seller’s shop.

STEP 3 – View Competitor’s Sales

Get a rough idea of how many sales that seller makes per year.

Take their total sales on Etsy and divide it by how many years they’ve been on Etsy.

You can’t know for sure how many sales they make each year, unless they’ve only been on the platform for one year.

An Etsy seller may have been on the platform for 3 years and have 3000 sales, but that doesn’t mean those sales have accumulated equally over the years. They may have only sold 5 items their first year and then really ramped up their marketing in the past 2 years to increase sales.

STEP 4 – Calculate Competitor’s Average Price

The prices of their products may vary, but you can find a rough average by adding the prices of (what seem to be) their most popular products, and then dividing by the number of price points they have.

For example, if my competitor offered 3 different candles at $20, $30, and $40, I would add those prices together and then divide by 3 (the number of different price points).

Their average price point is approximately $30.

If they have 50 items listed and only 2 of those listings are for the $20 candle, I may assume it’s not very popular and simply find the price average based on the $30 and $40 price points.

STEP 5 – Multiply Price by Sales

Now you can multiply how many sales your competitor has by their average price point, to get an idea of their total revenue.

Again, you can divide the total revenue by how many years they’ve been selling on Etsy to get a rough idea of how much they sell in a year.

Keep in mind, the number you’re getting isrevenue. There are material costs, Etsy fees, marketing fees, etc. that will reduce how much of that money goes into the seller’s pocket.

STEP 6 – How Much Money YOU Can Make

Determine if you’re likely to make more or less money than them.

Be critical and consider if your photography, product descriptions, branding, etc. can be on par with the competitor your analyzing. If you know you’re not great at photography and will have to hire out that aspect to get anywhere near the quality of photos your competitor has, that will eat into your profit margins.

Also, do a bit of digging to determine how they’re marketing their shop.

Does their listing appear as an Ad on Etsy?

If you’re not willing to spend money on ads, that may decrease how many sales you make in comparison to their shop.

Do they have a Facebook page, Instagram shop, Pinterest account?

How active are they on those social media platforms? How many followers do they have? Do they seem to be driving traffic from their social media accounts to their Etsy shop? If they have large followings on social media and seem to be relying heavily on those accounts to drive traffic to their Etsy shop, and you’re starting from scratch with your business’s social media accounts, it may take you a while to reach the yearly sales your competitor appears to have.

Do they have a website?

Their website may also bring in sales that aren’t accounted for on Etsy. Or, their website may simply be a blog that helps drive traffic to their Etsy shop. Consider if you’ll be setting up a website.

Do they have a newsletter?

Email marketing is one of the most effective marketing techniques. If they have a newsletter and you don’t plan on setting one up, you may not be able to make as many sales as they do.

All of these factors, and more, will determine how much money you can make on Etsy.

What are the transaction fees?

There are many fees when selling on Etsy (you can find a full breakdown here of optional and mandatory fees). Etsy recently increased its transaction fee from 5% to 6.5%.

This is a fee charged on thetotalof each transaction. For example, if I charged a customer $50 USD total for a product, Etsy will take $3.25 USD of that sale.

On top of that transaction fee you will also be charged a listing fee ($0.20 USD) and an Etsy Payment Fee (3% + $0.25USD = $1.75 USD). Etsy Payments is similar to PayPal, Stripe, etc.; they charge you a fee to process each online payment.

At minimum, you will be giving Etsy $5.20 USD from a $50 sale, which works out to a 10.4% commission for Etsy on your sale.

For a better understanding of how fees work and a full break down, check out: How Much Does Etsy Take Per Sale?

Who pays for shipping on Etsy?

The customer should always pay for shipping, in one way or another.

Customers pay for every expense of your business. Although they’re buying the product, there are many steps that come before that product is ready for them to buy.

Customers may not think about everything it takes to get a product to market, but you must keep each step in mind and work those costs into product prices.The money your business makes must cover every single cost of your business, such as:

Your hours to photograph, upload, and edit product images
Etsy listing and transaction fees
The cost of the label you place on each item
The cost of the box and bubble wrap you ship an item in
Your time to drive to the post office
Etc.

And since customers paying you money for your products is likely the only way your business makes money (unless you have other revenue streams), the money your customers pay you must cover all of those costs. You cannot pay for them out of your own pocket.

For customers to pay shipping costs, even when you’re offering free shipping, you must work those shipping costs into your prices.

You can either:

1 – leave prices the same and reduce your profits (this may be acceptable if you already have high profit margins)

2 – increase your prices to include shipping costs (this may be acceptable if your prices are below average)

3 – increase prices to include some of the shipping costs and reduce your profits to cover the rest.

The first step is to look at your numbers and make sure your prices are covering ALL expenses and leaving you with a profit…at wholesale prices.

Please follow this guide for therightway to price handmade products.

When handmade business owners don’t add proper markups to their prices (this article will teach you the rightway), that’s when they get in trouble with changes, such as Etsy encouraging free shipping or even a recession.

Without healthy profit margins, your business can’t put money aside for a rainy day or have the wiggle room to adjust prices, offer discounts, etc.

Once your products are priced properly, you can adjust your shipping costs to be more appealing to the customers, which will help with your sales.

Do you have to charge taxes on Etsy?

Taxes can cause confusion for business owners. There are a few things you must consider when it comes to taxes:

Sales tax
Income tax
Expenses

It’s up to the business owner to understand and follow ALL laws, including tax laws. Which vary depending on what type of business you have, your sales, where you run your business, where you ship to, and other factors. You’ll find more information in: Laws for Selling Handmade.

SALES TAX

Due to new laws in some states that affect online marketplaces, Etsy has begun calculating, collecting, and remitting sales tax for sellers when they’re shipping items to certain states. The list of states may change if/when more states introduce similar laws.

It’s important to note: just because Etsy is not calculating, collecting, and remitting sale taxes for all locations, does not mean your handmade business is not responsible to do so.

INCOME TAX

If you sell your products and make a profit, you’re considered a business and must report your income when you file income taxes. How you report your income will depend on what type of business you set up (e.g. sole proprietor, partnership, LLC, Corporation, etc.).

You pay taxes on your income, which is the money left once you deduct expenses and costs of goods sold. So you must track and keep records of your expenses and costs so you can reduce the amount you pay taxes on. This brings me to the next point…

EXPENSES

If you work out of your home, use your car for business, travel for trade shows, etc. you may be able to write off part of those expenses as indirect business expenses.

What’s considered a business expense and how much of that expense can be filed varies depending on your business and jurisdiction.

The more you can (*legally) write off as an expense, the less income you have to pay taxes on. So it’s important to properly track your business expenses.

Etsy may charge sales tax on your behalf, but not always.

HOW TO BOOST SALES ON ETSY

There are many factors that play a role in increasing Etsy sales. Make sure you take these 7 essential stepsbeforeyou set up your Etsy shop, and consider each factor below.

PRODUCTS

>> Selling profitable products: The Most Profitable Crafts to Sell

>> Having the right selection of products:How to Know if You’re Offering Too Many Products

>> Offer products that make it easy for a new customer to dip their toes in the water:How to Create an Entry-Level Product for your Handmade Business

PROMOTION

The success of many Etsy shops has less to do withwhatthey sell and more to do with howthey promote and sell it. These articles may help:

>>How to Promote your Handmade Business

>>How to Find More Customers for your Handmade Business

>>How to Get Etsy Sales From Pinterest

GREAT PHOTOS

Your photos mustsellyour products. Customers can touch/pick up/try on products when shopping online so your photos and product descriptions must communicate enough information for shoppers to make informed decisions. Without enough information, shoppers won’t buy.

GOOD SALES STRATEGIES

>> Write great product descriptions:

>> Make it hard for shoppers to choose your competitors over you. Here’s how.

>> Use effective sales strategies when people are in your shop: The Most Effective Sales Technique for a Handmade Business

>> Set up a sales funnel for your business. Most shoppers aren’t ready to buy the first time they visit your shop. So it’s important to have a way to stay in touch with them. A sales funnel is the easiest and most effective way:How to Set Up a Sales Funnel for your Handmade Business

WORKINGWITHETSY

Etsy is constantly changing and your business must work with those changes to continue seeing sales on the platform. I cover the most recent changes Etsy has made and how your shop can adapt to them here:What is Going on with Etsy?

HOW TO KNOW IF SELLING ON ETSY IS WORTH IT FOR YOUR HANDMADE BUSINESS

If you’ve been selling on Etsy for a while, you may be wondering if it’s worth it for you to continue selling on it.

As Etsy continues to change its algorithm, update its rules, and grow, more and more makers are questioning if Etsy is worth it in 2020.

Should people with Etsy shops continue to put the effort into them and for those who don’t have one, should they start one? Let’s find your answer.

The bottom line is, Etsy is worth itIF you make a profit from it.

Countless forum threads with sellers stating their sales are down or that Etsy is “dead” or “dying”, doesn’t make it true or make Etsy any less useful to makers.

Obviously, Etsy IS worth it for many businesses or the platform wouldn’t continue to grow (as The Wall Street Journal pointed out) and there wouldn’t be sellers continuing to support the platform.

So, the question isn’t: is Etsy worth it?

It’s: is Etsy worth it for your business?

There isn’t a blanket statement that applies to all businesses. Just because one person says Etsy is 100% worth the time and money investment, does not mean it’s worth it for your business.

And on the other hand, if you have an Etsy shop up and running and are profiting from it, it’s worth it for you. Don’t listen to the “Etsy is dead” or “Etsy has lost its soul” opinions. It’s working for you and that’s all the matters.

But if you’re not sure if your Etsy shop is profiting or if it’s quite a fit, the following questions will help you decide.

Answer the following 10 questions for your business:

1 – HOW DO YOU PREFER TO SELL?

First and foremost, think about if you’re excited to sell on Etsy. Do you enjoy putting time into your shop or does the idea of starting an Etsy shop excite you?

I’m a big believer in the idea that passion gets results.

If the thought of Etsy fills you with dread, you’re not going to want to put time into it and you won’t be putting your best foot forward when you do spend time on it. That will be reflected in your results.

If you’ve been thinking about setting up an Etsy shop for a while but just can’t get motivated to take the first step, maybe that’s an indication that it’s not the right platform for you, regardless of how much success others have had on it.

One important lesson I’ve learned from over a decade of running my own businesses is: there’s no one size fits all.

It can be frustrating when you’re following the steps that worked for another business and it’s just not working for you.

But on the other hand, it’s exciting. You can pave your own path.

I used to be filled with dread thinking there was going to be a day I would have to go back on television, have more and more, and bigger and bigger media interviews, or even have to talk to a room full of employees.

But I’ve slowly discovered that just because most businesses use media for marketing and dream of having an entire team of people working on their business, doesn’t mean that had to be my path.

You can make your own goals and you can achieve them in a way that makes you happy. Passion must be behind everything you do and only you know what sparks that passion.

If sitting behind a computer and posting to Etsy doesn’t make you happy, look into selling at craft shows, selling wholesale to retailers (here’s how to attract wholesale orders at craft shows), or other ways to sell your products locally (here are lots of ways)

You may even find running your own website is more rewarding than an Etsy shop because you get more control over the design and functionality of it.

Consider if Etsy aligns with your passions and skills.

2 – WHAT ARE YOUR PROFIT MARGINS?

For any business to survive, it must have profits. And you must know how much you profit from each sale before you can make solid decisions for your business, such as which sales platforms to use.

*Profit is the money left once you pay for your expenses and pay yourself a wage.

As I mention in The Success Planner, profits should be used to determine how much money you put towards growth.

Based on your profits, Etsy may be a better fit for your business than a sales channel such as craft shows.

For example, let’s say last month you spent $100 on expenses (e.g. materials, Etsy listings, marketing, etc.) and your wages total $100. If you sell all the products you made for $200, you’ve earned your $200 back and can repeat what you did last month. There is no profit and no extra money to spend on more supplies, marketing efforts, sales channels, or wages.

If you earned $400 dollars from selling all the products you made, you’d have an extra $200 to play with next month. You could put more money towards products, marketing, and selling to earn more than you did last month. With that profit, you can also pay yourself more so you’re not just an employee getting paid for the hours put in.

The expense of selling through Etsy is lower, and lower risk, than selling at a craft show, so if you have lower profit margins, Etsy may be the better choice between the two.

Etsy is also a better choice when compared to selling wholesale if you have low profit margins.

However, you may find that making sales through your own website is the best option and may not cut into your profits as much as Etsy does.

You will be charged transaction fees either way if you’re using a service such as PayPal or Stripe to collect payments online.

However, Etsy charges a listing fee for every item, which you won’t have with your own website. You will have domain and hosting fees when running your own website, but those may be lower than Etsy listing fees, depending on your business.

Know your profit margins and how much each sales channel eats into them to determine which is the best option for you.

3 – HOW DO YOUR CUSTOMERS SHOP?

Think about the product you’re selling, the market you’re targeting, and how your target market typically shops for your product.

Are they likely to search online for your product or visit a store and buy it when shopping for other products?

Etsy won’t be worth it for you if your typical customer doesn’t shop on Etsy.

For example, let’s say a vendor is selling high-end jewelry to be worn with evening and ball gowns. They’re targeting women who are in their 40’s to 50’s attending galas, charity dinners, operas, etc. When shopping for a special occasion, most people go to boutiques or department stores so they can try on a gown and see it with all the accessories; the clutch, earrings, necklace, etc.

It’s unlikely that a woman in her 50’s is going to buy a ball gown and then go to Etsy to find high-end jewelry to go with it. She wants to see the jewelry in person and try it with the dress before deciding on it. Selling that jewelry wholesale to high-end boutiques carrying special occasion wear would be a better option than selling it through Etsy.

On the other hand, a woman in her 30’s who just saw Jessica Biel wearing an amazing pair of earrings on the red carpet won’t go from store to store looking for something similar. It’s easier for her to hop online, type “Jessica Biel earrings at MTV Awards” or a description of the earrings into Google and find something similar. In this case, Etsy would be a good option (if the proper SEO tactics were in place).

Consider your target market and if those customers typically head online to shop for your product.

If the answer is yes, start researching which keywords your target market might type into a search bar and create Etsy listings using those same keywords.

4 – WHAT IS YOUR ROI?

As mentioned in The Success Planner, it’s important to track how much time and money goes into each major task on your to-do list and how much that task earned you so you can determine if it’s actually worth your time and money.

That’s a task’s ROI; return on investment.

Once you’re set up on Etsy, you need to track how many hours and dollars you put into keeping your shop updated, promoting your shop, communicating with buyers, shipping orders, etc., and how much money you get back from it.

>> If you spend $100 each month on listing fees, taking photos, creating listings, promoting those listings on social media, etc. but you only sell 2 items per month from Etsy and that results in $50 of revenue, you’re NOTmaking a return on investment.

>> If you earn $100 in revenue from Etsy, you’d be breaking even.

>> And if you earn more than $100 in revenue from Etsy, you’d be making a return on investment. But then the question is; how much?

If you put $100 into Etsy in a month and earn $110 back from it, that’s only $10 profit. Is all the time and money you put into Etsy worth $10 profit or would that $100 be better spent somewhere else?

Know where your sales are coming from and how much you’re profiting after the time and money spent on the sales channel is deducted.

You may find Etsy doesn’t produce enough sales or profit to justify all the hours and expenses it requires.

If another sales channel brings you more sales and requires less time and money to make those sales, it deserves more of your time and money.

5 – DO YOUR PRODUCTS STAND OUT?

Take a look at the category your products fall under and scope out your competition.

In most cases, your products will be competing with thousands of similar products.

If you don’t have something that sets your products apart (aside from being “made by you” or being “your designs”) you may have a hard time making sales on Etsy.

When there are several similar options to choose from, consumers will go for the cheapest, quickest, or most convenient option unless there’s a valuable reason not to.

When you put all the work into getting people to your website, they’re only seeing your products and aren’t distracted by millions of other listings.

At craft shows, there are usually only one or two other vendors selling similar items to you.

Consider how your products will do when placed next to thousands of listings on Etsy. Will they catch eyes and encourage people to click or get lost in a sea of photos?

6 – WHAT TYPE OF FEEDBACK DO YOUR PRODUCTS GET?

Different products attract different types of customers and feedback. And, everyone has an opinion.

If your product’s features are subjective they may garner a wide range of reviews (e.g. “oversized” may be big to some and not big enough to others, “subtly scented” may be too strong for some and too weak for others).

With online shoppers, you have to make it crystal clear what you’re selling so customers know exactly what to expect.

If a customer receives something different than what they were expecting, based on photos, they may not be happy and leave a negative review.

For example, selling a moisturizer deemed “perfect for summer” is open to interpretation. Some people prefer lightweight oils for summer while others want oil-free options to avoid that greasy feeling. The moisturizer is likely to be too light for some but too heavy for others, and could result in mixed reviews.

On Etsy, a negative review is permanent (unless it violates policies).

Even if it’s completely unfair, simply their opinion and not a reflection of your product, or even if they made a mistake when ordering and are making it your problem, customers can leave a review and it’s on your permanent Etsy records.

On your own website, you’re in control of what appears. So if a Negative Nelly leaves an unfair review, it’s your choice if you want to display it.

Obviously, you want customers to be satisfied with their purchase and for everyone to leave a good review.

However, if your products read differently online than in person, and are better received when one is able to pick them up, handle them, see the quality, etc. they may be better suited for offline sales.

7 – HOW DO YOUR PRODUCTS SHIP?

Factor in how easily your products ship and how much it costs to ship. Many sales are abandoned because of high shipping fees.

The bulk of users on Etsy reside in the US, so if you don’t live in the US and it costs a lot of money to ship your products to the US, you may want to look at a different online marketplace (there’s a long list here), considering starting your own website and working on SEO for your product name combined with your location, or focusing on selling locally offline.

Also, consider how easy it is for you to stay on top of shipments. Do you have a system in place to track orders, package them for shipping, and get them off to buyers in a timely manner?

Online shoppers want their items to ship quickly.

Many negative reviews left on Etsy shops have to do with wait time or lack of communication from the Etsy seller letting them know when to expect their item.

If you can’t get to the post office each week or your products have a long lead time (i.e. you custom make each order and it takes you 2 weeks before an item is ready to ship), online selling may be difficult for you.

8 – WHAT ARE YOUR COMPUTER SKILLS?

Etsy makes it fairly easy to set up an online shop, especially when comparing it to setting up your own website.

If you want to have an online presence but you have minimal computer skills, Etsy is likely your best option.

There are several tutorials that will walk you through how to set up your shop and their interface is pretty user-friendly.

Like anything, it will take some time to understand the platform and become comfortable with it, but if you have limited time to do so, my suggestion is to go for Etsy over setting up your own website.

Once you become comfortable with using Etsy, you can ease into the idea of starting your own website.

9 – HOW WILL YOU GET TRAFFIC?

One thing is for sure; Etsy sellers can no longer rely on adding listings to their shop and watching views and sales pour in.

If you hate social media and other forms on online marketing, it’s going to be hard to get traffic to your Etsy shop and may not be worth it for you to use the platform.

When selling online, it also requires you to invest time into SEO (search engine optimization).

>> Here’s a complete and easy-to-follow Etsy SEO guide

Etsy can help your listings show up in Google searches because Etsy has a good ranking on Google. However, within Etsy, they are constantly changing their algorithm and when and how a listing shows up on the platform.

Although Etsy might initially help attract Google shoppers, it’s easier to lose those shoppers to other sellers.

It may take longer to get your own website to rank on the first page of Google but once someone lands on your website, your products aren’t competing with millions of others just like them.

You decide what appears at the top of the page and you can keep your shoppers focused on your products.

You’ll also have an easier time getting someone on your newsletter list when they’re on your website vs. Etsy. Which is absolutely essential to your business.

Seriously, don’t wait. Set your newsletter up today. It’s free, will take 10 minutes and you don’t even need a website to start collecting email addresses. And here are 365+ ideas for what to send to your subscribers.

Etsy may be worth it for your business if you don’t have a lot of time and money to pour into SEO and getting traffic to your personal website (it can take years for your own website to start showing up on the first page of Google).

10 – WHAT ARE YOUR GOALS?

Where do you see your business in the coming years?

Do you want a business that is 100% online? Etsy may be a good starting point and support for your online business.

Do you want to open your own store one day? Perhaps focusing on selling wholesale to retailers is a better path. It may also be more effective to start your own website so you can slowly start to build traffic to it and it’s ready to go when you do open that store.

Do you want to focus on craft shows and make a few online sales? Etsy might be the perfect solution to that as you don’t have to build your own website, pay a developer, pay for hosting and a domain, etc.

Consider if selling on Etsy aligns with the vision you have for your business.

You may also be interested in:How to Make Selling on Etsy Easy

Are you starting an Etsy shop this year or shutting one down?

Finally understand why your hard work isn't resulting in more sales

Join over 18,000 others and sign up for the
Made Urban newsletter

Erin (Creator of Made Urban)

Hey, I’m Erin 🙂 I write about small business and craft show techniques I’ve learned from being a small business owner for almost 2 decades, selling at dozens of craft shows, and earning a diploma in Visual Communication Design. I hope you find my advice helpful!

Is Selling on Etsy Worth it in 2024? (Reviews & Alternatives) - Made Urban (2024)