The difference between replica and fake goods - Red Points (2024)

Last updated on: November 20, 2023

Counterfeits and replicas have always troubled the world of commerce. The OECD’s 2019 report gives context to the extent of this challenge by revealing that trade in such goods accounts for 3.3% of global trade. While there is a huge difference between replica and counterfeit, people tend to use the terms interchangeably, and there appears to be a vague line between the two.

Summary

• Replica goods and counterfeit goods both pose a huge challenge to brands.
• Counterfeit goods are different from replica goods.
• How brands can act against the ravaging effects of counterfeits and replicas online.

What are replica goods?

Replica goods are close copies of the original goods. Also referred to as knockoffs, they are acknowledged to be modeled after the original famous product. Therefore, even though they share a striking resemblance with the original goods, they are not passed off as being the real deal.

Replica goods are considered to be legitimate copies because they do not bear the branded product’s trademark. So, while a replica might have the same feature and functionality of a famous or branded product, it usually carries a different symbol or logo which is admittedly similar to the famous one.

As a result, they are not outrightly illegal.

Replica goods can be created to look similar to branded items in many various categories including but not limited to:

• Clothes
• Toys
• Shoes
• Handbags
• Phones
• Jewelry

While various online platforms aid deals in replica goods in different categories, brand owners in the fashion industry are having an exceptionally hard time with Reddit’s replica communities.

What are counterfeit goods?

Counterfeit goods can be defined as copies or imitations of a product that are intended to be taken as authentic and genuine in order to deceive a person.

Simply put, counterfeit goods are fake products that are made of cheaper substandard quality and are being sold under the name and trademark of another brand without authorization from the brand owner.

As a matter of fact, trafficking in counterfeit goods is criminalized and punishable under 18 United States Code, Sec 2320.

A core feature of counterfeit goods is that there is always the malicious intent to deceive and mislead buyers into believing that the product is authentic when it is actually the exact opposite. They are passed off as the genuine product. Therefore, counterfeit goods violate the trademark and other intellectual property rights of the owner of the authentic brand.

Counterfeiting further embraces the associated elements of copying the labeling, packaging, or any other expressive features of the genuine product.

Counterfeiters thrive because the counterfeit goods are sold at high prices far beyond the production cost, and unsuspecting buyers are willing to pay because they think they are buying the genuine product at a somewhat lower price.

Counterfeit goods are made in various categories of products such as:

• Pharmaceuticals
• Car and aircraft spare parts and accessories
• Gadgets and electronic products
• Clothes and accessories
• Luxury brands and items

Dangers of counterfeit goods

Counterfeit goods adversely impact brands, the users of the items, and even the environment. Their adverse effects are experienced in the following ways:

• Since these counterfeit goods are manufactured illegally, there is no compliance with the applicable safety standards during the process of production, and this can wreak havoc on the environment.
• Counterfeit goods are also produced using inferior materials in a bid to whittle down production costs as much as possible.
• Users of counterfeit goods can suffer harm or injury as a result of the hazardous substances or substandard materials used in production.
• The original brand owners can suffer financial losses as well as reputation damage due to the poor quality of the counterfeit goods being passed off as genuine.

The difference between replica and counterfeit goods

Having gotten a solid understanding of what counterfeit goods and replica goods are, it is only appropriate to consider what sets them apart.

The differences between them are:

• Counterfeit goods are produced with the malicious intent to deceive and mislead people into believing that the items are genuine when they are not. However, replica goods are not passed off as the original products. Instead, they are acknowledged to be merely identical to the branded goods.
• In many countries, counterfeit goods are frowned upon by the law and are thus illegal. However, replica goods are usually not considered illegal initially.
• Another difference between replica goods and counterfeit goods is that counterfeit goods bear the exact trademark of the original product, and also copy its labeling and packaging – a textbook case of trademark infringement. But replica goods carry a different logo or design element that is only similar to the famous product.

Conclusion

Both counterfeit goods and replica goods are seemingly endless intellectual property infringements that are prevalent in ecommerce. However, Red Points’ brand protection solution can help.

Thanks to our Intellectual Property software, Red Points functions as an online watchdog by scouring search engines for data such as text, manipulated or unaltered images to detect counterfeit goods and replica goods posted for sale.

These red flags are then pointed out to the brand owner to decide if they want to enforce their rights.

To get a comprehensive idea of our services and unique methods, you can download our brand protection product guide.